A Comparison of Makita vs Milwaukee

When it comes to power tools, two names often stand out: Makita and Milwaukee. Both brands have earned a reputation for producing reliable, high-quality tools that are favored by professionals and DIY enthusiasts alike. But how do you choose between them?

History of Makita and Milwaukee

Makita

Makita was founded in 1915 in Japan and initially started as an electric motor sales and repair company. Over the decades, Makita has grown into a global brand, renowned for its innovation in power tools and its commitment to quality. The company introduced its first cordless drill in 1978, setting a precedent for the industry.

Milwaukee

Milwaukee, on the other hand, was founded in 1924 in the United States. The company quickly gained a reputation for producing tools that could withstand the toughest job site conditions.

Milwaukee is known for its focus on heavy-duty tools and has been a leader in cordless technology with its M12 and M18 lines.

Power Tool and Battery Comparison

Both Makita and Milwaukee offer a wide range of tools, but there are some differences worth noting.

Comparing Power Tools

1. Impact Drivers

Makita XDT16

• Torque: 1,600 in-lbs
• Speed Settings: 4 (0-1,300, 0-2,800, 0-3,600 RPM)
• Weight: 3.3 lbs
• Run Time: Approximately 75 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: Excellent torque and speed settings for versatility. Compact and well-balanced, though slightly heavier than some competitors.

Milwaukee M18 Fuel 2853-20

• Torque: 2,000 in-lbs
• Speed Settings: 4 (0-1,000, 0-2,500, 0-3,200 RPM)
• Weight: 3.1 lbs
• Run Time: Up to 80 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: Superior torque and control with 4-mode drive control. Lightweight with fast charging, offering high performance in a compact form.

2. Oscillating Multi-Tools

Makita XMT03Z

• Oscillation Speed: 6,000-20,000 OPM
• Weight: 3.3 lbs
• Run Time: About 60 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: Versatile oscillation speeds and tool-free accessory changes. Effective for a variety of cutting and sanding tasks, though less powerful in very heavy-duty applications.

Milwaukee M18 Fuel 2626-20

• Oscillation Speed: 10,000-20,000 OPM
• Weight: 3.1 lbs
• Run Time: Approximately 75 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: High oscillation speeds and versatile performance. Quick-change system and durable, ideal for heavy-duty tasks.

3. Miter Saws

Makita LS1219L

• Blade Size: 12-inch
• Cut Capacity: 15-inch crosscut
• Weight: 60 lbs
• Testing Results: High cutting capacity and precision with a laser guide for accuracy. Robust build, though quite heavy and less portable.

Milwaukee M18 Fuel 2739-20

• Blade Size: 12-inch
• Cut Capacity: 14-inch crosscut
• Weight: 50 lbs
• Testing Results: Exceptional cutting capacity and efficiency in a cordless model. Well-balanced with advanced features for precise cuts.

4. Cordless Circular Saws

Makita XSS02Z Blade Size: 7-1/4 inch

• Cut Depth: 2-5/8 inch at 90
• Weight: 7.3 lbs
• Run Time: Around 60 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: Good cutting depth and power. Lighter than many competitors but can be less powerful for very tough cuts.

Milwaukee M18 Fuel 2732-20

• Blade Size: 7-1/4 inch
• Cut Depth: 2-1/2 inch at 90°
• Weight: 8.6 lbs
• Run Time: Up to 75 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: High RPM and efficient cutting with a slightly heavier design. Provides excellent power and runtime.

5. Cordless Drills

Makita XFD10R

• Torque: 480 in-lbs
• Speed Settings: 2 (0-600, 0-1,900 RPM)
• Weight: 3.4 lbs
• Run Time: About 75 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: Reliable torque and good balance. Simple design with effective performance for various tasks.

Milwaukee M18 Fuel 2804-20

• Torque: 1,200 in-lbs
• Speed Settings: 2 (0-550, 0-2,000 RPM)
• Weight: 3.2 lbs
• Run Time: Up to 90 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: High torque and excellent performance. Compact and ergonomic, offering strong power in a lighter design.

6. Cordless Reciprocating Saws

Makita XRJ05Z

• Stroke Length: 1-1/4 inch
• Speed: 0-2,800 SPM
• Weight: 7.9 lbs
• Run Time: Approximately 60 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: Effective for heavy-duty cutting with a robust design. Bulkier and heavier compared to some newer models.

Milwaukee M18 Fuel 2720-20

• Stroke Length: 1-1/4 inch
• Speed: 0-3,000 SPM
• Weight: 6.0 lbs
• Run Time: Up to 75 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: High speed and cutting power with ergonomic design. Efficient and effective for tough applications.

7. Cordless Routers

Makita XTR01Z

• Speed: 10,000-30,000 RPM
• Weight: 3.9 lbs
• Run Time: About 60 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: Versatile with variable speed control and precision. Slightly heavier for extended use.

Milwaukee M18 Fuel 2723-20

• Speed: 10,000-31,000 RPM
• Weight: 4.0 lbs
• Run Time: Up to 75 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: High power and speed with smooth operation. Lightweight and efficient for various routing tasks.

8. Cordless Rear Handle Worm Drive Circular Saws

Makita XSH03Z

• Blade Size: 7-1/4 inch
• Cut Depth: 2-5/8 inch at 90°
• Weight: 10.0 lbs
• Run Time: Around 60 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: Strong cutting power with a robust build. Heavier and less maneuverable compared to newer models.

Milwaukee M18 Fuel 2732-20

• Blade Size: 7-1/4 inch
• Cut Depth: 2-1/2 inch at 90°
• Weight: 10.2 lbs
• Run Time: Up to 75 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: Lightweight with excellent cutting performance. Advanced features and high efficiency.

9. Cordless Jigsaws

Makita XVJ03Z

• Stroke Length: 1 inch
• Speed: 0-2,800 SPM
• Weight: 5.3 lbs
• Run Time: Approximately 60 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: Effective for precision cuts with adjustable settings. Heavier for extended use.

Milwaukee M18 Fuel 2737-20

• Stroke Length: 1 inch
• Speed: 0-3,500 SPM
• Weight: 5.1 lbs
• Run Time: Up to 75 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: High speed and precision with tool-free blade changes. High performance but can be noisy.

10. 12V Cordless Impact Drivers

Makita TD022D

• Torque: 970 in-lbs
• Speed Settings: 2 (0-2,000 RPM)
• Weight: 2.3 lbs
• Run Time: About 50 minutes with a 2.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: Compact and lightweight, suitable for light to medium tasks. Less powerful than some competitors.

Milwaukee M12 Fuel 2553-20

• Torque: 1,300 in-lbs
• Speed Settings: 4 (0-1,000, 0-2,500, 0-3,200 RPM)
• Weight: 2.3 lbs
• Run Time: Up to 55 minutes with a 2.0Ah battery
• Testing Results: High torque and versatility in a compact form. Multiple modes offer enhanced control.

11. Nail Guns

Makita XNB01Z

• Type: 18-gauge finish nailer
• Weight: 5.3 lbs
• Run Time: N/A (air-driven)
• Testing Results: Reliable and accurate with tool-free depth adjustment. Less powerful for heavy applications.

Milwaukee M18 Fuel 2746-21

• Type: 18-gauge finish nailer
• Weight: 4.9 lbs
• Run Time: Approximately 600 nails per charge
• Testing Results: High efficiency and fast firing with excellent battery life. Lightweight and ergonomic.

Conclusion

Makita tools are lauded for their precision, solid build quality, and effective battery performance, making them a dependable choice for professionals. Milwaukee tools stand out for their advanced technology, superior battery performance, and ergonomic design, delivering high power and efficiency, particularly in demanding applications. While Makita excels in reliability and robust design, Milwaukee offers cutting-edge features and top-tier battery technology, providing a competitive edge in high-performance tasks.

Comparing Batteries

When choosing power tools, the performance of the battery is crucial for efficiency and effectiveness. Makita and Milwaukee both offer advanced battery systems that are integral to their respective tools. Here’s a comparison of their key battery technologies and performance metrics:

Makita Batteries

18V LXT Lithium-Ion Batteries

• Battery Types: 1.5Ah, 3.0Ah, 4.0Ah, 5.0Ah, 6.0Ah
• Technology: LXT (Lithium-Ion eXtreme Technology) provides long-lasting power and a range of amp-hour options to suit various tasks.
• Performance:
  • Run Time: The run time varies by capacity. For instance, a 5.0Ah battery typically provides around 60-75 minutes of operation, depending on the tool and usage.
  • Charge Time: Generally between 30 to 45 minutes with a rapid charger.
• Strengths: Reliable performance with good power-to-weight ratio. Durable and well-suited for a range of applications.
• Drawbacks: The charge time can be longer compared to some newer rapid-charging technologies. Higher capacity batteries add weight.

12V CXT Lithium-Ion Batteries

• Battery Types: 2.0Ah, 4.0Ah
• Technology: CXT (Compact eXtreme Technology) provides compact and lightweight options for smaller tools.
• Performance:
  • Run Time: Typically around 30-50 minutes with a 2.0Ah battery, depending on the tool.
  • Charge Time: Approximately 30 minutes with a rapid charger.
• Strengths: Compact design offers enhanced portability and ease of use with smaller tools.
• Drawbacks: Lower run time and power compared to 18V LXT batteries. Less suitable for heavy-duty tasks.

Milwaukee Batteries

M18 REDLITHIUM Batteries

• Battery Types: 1.5Ah, 2.0Ah, 3.0Ah, 5.0Ah, 6.0Ah, 9.0Ah, 12.0Ah
• Technology: REDLITHIUM technology includes advanced battery management for longer run times, more power, and better performance in extreme conditions.
• Performance:
  • Run Time: Up to 90 minutes with a 5.0Ah battery, depending on the tool and usage. High-capacity batteries (e.g., 9.0Ah) can last significantly longer.
  • Charge Time: Rapid charging options can charge a 5.0Ah battery in about 30 minutes.
• Strengths: Excellent run times, superior performance in cold weather, and fast charging. REDLINK PLUS™ technology optimizes performance and prevents overheating.
• Drawbacks: Higher cost compared to some competitors. Larger capacity batteries add weight.

M12 REDLITHIUM Batteries

• Battery Types: 1.5Ah, 2.0Ah, 4.0Ah
• Technology: REDLITHIUM technology for compact tools, offering reliable performance in a smaller form factor.
• Performance:
  • Run Time: Around 30-55 minutes with a 2.0Ah battery, varying by tool.
  • Charge Time: About 30 minutes with a rapid charger.
• Strengths: Compact and lightweight, ideal for smaller, lighter tools. Quick charging and good performance for its size.
• Drawbacks: Limited capacity and run time compared to M18 batteries. Less suitable for high-demand applications.

Comparison Summary

• Run Time and Power: Milwaukee’s REDLITHIUM batteries generally offer longer run times and superior performance in extreme conditions compared to Makita’s LXT and CXT batteries. Milwaukee’s higher-capacity options (9.0Ah and 12.0Ah) are particularly notable for extended use and demanding tasks.
• Charging Speed: Milwaukee’s rapid-charging technology often results in faster charge times compared to Makita’s batteries, especially with their 5.0Ah and higher capacity options.
• Portability and Size: Makita’s 12V CXT batteries are more compact and lightweight, making them ideal for smaller tools and applications where portability is crucial. Milwaukee’s M12 REDLITHIUM batteries also offer compact sizes but with a focus on providing efficient power and quick charging.
• Durability and Performance: Both brands offer durable batteries, but Milwaukee’s REDLITHIUM technology includes additional features like REDLINK PLUS™ to protect against overheating and overload, enhancing performance in tough conditions.

In summary, Makita batteries are reliable and well-suited for a broad range of applications with a focus on durability and good performance. Milwaukee batteries, particularly the REDLITHIUM and HIGH OUTPUT series, excel in providing extended run times, fast charging, and superior performance under extreme conditions, offering a slight edge in battery technology and efficiency.

Price and Warranty

Makita Pricing and Warranty

Makita tools are competitively priced, often slightly lower than Milwaukee. They offer a 3-year warranty on most of their tools and batteries, which provides good peace of mind for users.

Milwaukee Pricing and Warranty

Milwaukee tools tend to be priced a bit higher, reflecting their focus on heavy-duty applications. They also offer a 5-year warranty on most tools and a 2-year warranty on batteries, which is one of the best in the industry.

Tools and Batteries Summary

Makita and Milwaukee are both leading brands known for their high-quality power tools and advanced battery technologies. Each brand excels in different areas, catering to varied needs and preferences.

Tools

• Makita:
  • Strengths: Makita tools are celebrated for their precision, durability, and robust build quality. They offer a range of well-engineered tools, including impact drivers, oscillating multi-tools, and cordless drills. Makita tools are known for their balance and reliable performance, making them suitable for both professionals and DIY enthusiasts.
  • Drawbacks: Some Makita tools can be heavier, and their battery technology, while reliable, may not always match the rapid advancements seen in Milwaukee’s lineup. Higher-end Makita tools can also be more expensive.
• Milwaukee:
  • Strengths: Milwaukee tools are renowned for their innovative technology and high performance. They incorporate features like POWERSTATE™ motors and REDLINK PLUS™ electronics for enhanced power and efficiency. Milwaukee’s tools are designed for heavy-duty applications, offering advanced functionality and ergonomics.
  • Drawbacks: Milwaukee tools generally come at a higher price point, and their advanced features may involve a steeper learning curve for some users. Additionally, some models can be bulkier compared to competitors.

Batteries

• Makita:
  • Strengths: Makita’s 18V LXT and 12V CXT battery systems are reliable and offer good performance with a range of amp-hour options. The 18V LXT batteries provide robust power and solid runtime, while the 12V CXT batteries are compact and lightweight, ideal for smaller tools.
  • Drawbacks: Makita batteries can have longer charge times compared to some newer technologies, and the higher capacity batteries add weight, which can impact tool balance and comfort.
• Milwaukee:
  • Strengths: Milwaukee’s REDLITHIUM and HIGH OUTPUT batteries are known for their extended run times, fast charging capabilities, and performance in extreme conditions. The M18 REDLITHIUM batteries offer superior power and durability, while the M12 REDLITHIUM batteries are compact yet efficient.
  • Drawbacks: Milwaukee batteries tend to be more expensive, and the higher capacity options can add weight. The advanced features, while beneficial, may be complex for some users to fully utilize.

Conclusion

In summary, Makita is a solid choice for those seeking durable and precise tools with reliable battery performance. Milwaukee stands out for its cutting-edge technology, high performance, and advanced battery systems that excel in providing extended run times and rapid charging. Makita excels in tool design and reliability, while Milwaukee offers superior battery technology and innovation. The choice between the two brands will largely depend on specific needs, such as tool performance, battery longevity, and budget.